Migrated to:
https://www.printables.com/model/544954-elmers-glue-cap
You busted off the stuck applicator cap of your Elmer's trying to open it with the pliers.
You gonna throw that whole thing out?
I don't think so.
Fits my 4 and 8 oz bottles of Elmer's White and Carpenter's glues, and Carpenter's MAX. No applicator on this top - it's just a flat closure. Use q-tips or popsicle sticks or something.